Reading 05

From the readings, I learned that the Challenger disaster was caused by a chain of events initiated by a failed seal on a rocket booster. There was erosion of an O Ring caused by the cold temperatures of the day of that launch that allowed a stream of hot gas to ignite an external fuel tank. Although the launch team was warned about the dangers of going through with the launch in such cold temperatures (near 31 degrees when 54 degrees was recommended), they decided to accept the risks and proceed as planned.  
I believe that Roger Boisjoly was ethical in sharing his information regarding the dangers of proceeding with the launch in cold temperature. In this situation, and in many others like it, I believe that individuals have the responsibility to stand up for what they believe is right. By voicing his opinion pre-launch Roger was watching out for the lives of the astronauts on board the space shuttle. Roger was simply valuing the lives of those astronauts over the other consequences (such as monetary costs) that might have been faced if NASA were to postpone the launch to a later, warmer day. I am in a just war theory class this semester and one topic we discussed was what a soldier is supposed to do when their commander orders them to do something that is unjust. In war, a soldier has the responsibly to disobey a manifestly unlawful order, for example, intentionally and for no reason killing non-combatants. In this case I think of Roger as a soldier alerting/disobeying his commander for moral and ethical reasons. By expressing the dangers of moving forward with the launch I believe that Roger took the high road, even it is frowned upon as disobeying orders.
While I do believe that a company does have the right to retaliate against an employee who clearly disobeys its wishes, I support Roger Boisjoly in this case. I do not believe that trying to cover up that they knew about the dangers of launching the space shuttle in cold conditions if morally or ethically right. Those affected by the tragedy and the public have the right to know what precautions were taken and/ignored in the preparation for the launch.

Whistleblowing can be a source of information to stop unfortunate tragedies from happening. In this case, if NASA had listened to the warnings and decided to postpone the launch of the Challenger lives could have been saved and there would not have been the halt in the space program in the following years. In addition, the whistleblower does not have to live with the guilt of not speaking out in a case where someone does know something is wrong and withholds that information. Sometimes, I would imagine that not living with the guilt of withholding information would, or could, make destroying your career worth it. In my opinion, we all have the responsibility to watch out for not only ourselves but those around us, and if we are called to risk our career to try to save the lives of others then we must.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Project 02

One of the most important things that I have learned throughout my life and especially the job search process is the importance of first impressions. It is important to note that not all first impressions are made when you meet someone face to face for the first time; recruiters or those reviewing your job application will immediately cross you off their list if your resume does not satisfy what they are looking for. While it is obviously important that your skill set and other requirements such as GPA and experience to match, I would argue that the layout and presentation of the information on your resume is more important. One career advisor once told me that, during her role as a talent recruiter, if she was reviewing resumes and she came to one that was not easily readable and was hard to follow, she wouldn’t even bother to look at the applicant’s name, she would place the resume directly in the “NO” pile. Continuing with the conversation I had with that same advisor, she also str
Read more

Reading 01

I believe that there are two distinct definitions of the word hacker, one that applies to those within the computer science community and one used by those who are not. While, as mentioned in the article “The Word ‘Hacker',” individuals in the programming community generally have a positive outlook on the word “hacker,” while members of the general public have a more sinister understanding of the word. Those not familiar with computer science and with the role programmers or hackers play typically view hackers as only being those who are committing crimes, violating privacy, lack ethics, and are harming our world in the end. While it is certainly true that there are many programmers who use their skills in a detrimental and adverse way, many of those within the technology community aspire to use their hacking to enable our world to be more efficient, secure, and productive. It is often over-looked by the general public that in order to stop a criminal hacker, often times someone m
Read more

Introduction

Hi, I am Rylan, a senior Economics Major and Computing & Digital Technologies Minor living in Duncan Hall. I transferred to Notre Dame prior to my sophomore year here as a part of the Holy Cross-Notre Dame Gateway Program. Our group of 20 students were only the second to be accepted into that new arrangement where we were guaranteed acceptance as a transfer if, as a freshman, we achieved a certain grade point average in our classes both at Holy Cross and at Notre Dame. It was a stressful, but rewarding, year and I am so glad I persisted. The friends that I have made and the experiences I have been through thus far have been amazing.   I am from Lake Forest, Illinois, north of Chicago where I spend most of my free time playing golf or running, and following the World Champion Chicago Cubs. Throughout my childhood, I grew up loving numbers and statistics, calculating distances, analyzing relationships, thinking about how things work, and I always knew I wanted to do something that
Read more